Water Softener Compare

What Size Water Softener for a Family of Two?

The number

24,000 grains, for 2 people at 11 gpg. That works out to about 11,550 grains of hardness a week, sized to regenerate roughly once every seven days.

Two people on average municipal water is the one case where the entry-level unit genuinely can be enough, and it is also the case where buyers most often talk themselves into paying for capacity they will never reach.

The arithmetic lands on the smallest standard size, and the real question is whether to take it or step up one. The price gap to a 32,000-grain unit is usually small, and that step buys headroom for a guest, a water-hungry appliance, or hardness that turns out above the utility average. If your hardness figure came from a municipal report rather than your own test, take the step up.

The opposite error costs more. A softener sized for six people in a two-person house sits a long time between regenerations, and resin that sits idle can channel, so the bed stops making even contact with the water passing through it.

If the two of you are out of the house most days, actual consumption runs well under the 75 gallons per person the formula assumes, which pushes you further toward the smaller end rather than the larger.

What this size costs to run

A family of four gets through roughly one 40-pound bag of salt a month, which is the figure everything else scales from. At 2 people that works out to about 0.5 bags a month, so roughly $30 to $60 a year at $5 to $10 a bag.

At 11,550 grains a week against a 24,000-grain unit, expect regeneration roughly every couple of weeks once the head has learned the household pattern. Each cycle also sends water to the drain, between about 21 and 55 gallons depending on the unit, which is worth checking against the spec if you are on a septic field.

Salt is the running cost that people notice. The one they miss is resin, which lasts 10 to 15 years on municipal water and 5 to 10 on iron-bearing well water, and costs $200 to $400 to replace. On this water you should get the longer end of that range.

Units that fit this size

Specs read from manufacturer pages. Each unit's page lists its source and check date. “—” means not yet sourced, never guessed.

Your numbers are not these numbers

This page assumes 11 gpg and no iron. Hardness varies enormously between water supplies and it moves the answer more than one extra person does, so run your own figures.

What size water softener do you need?

Recommended capacity

24,000 grains

2 people × 75 gal/day × 11.0 gpg = 11,550 grains/week, sized for one regeneration per week at usable capacity.

Units that fit

Specs read from manufacturer pages. Each unit's page lists its source and check date. “—” means not yet sourced, never guessed.

Where to go next

Once you have a capacity, the cost guide shows what that size runs and why identical capacities vary by three times in price. If you have not decided on type yet, salt-based vs salt-free comes first, because a conditioner does not soften water and this calculation does not apply to one.